Cold fusion claims that don’t bear scrutiny | Letters

May Be Interested In:Pope’s treatment changed due to ‘complex’ clinical situation, Vatican says


I was disappointed to see a letter promoting a pseudo-scientific fringe theory (Cold fusion may be a viable energy alternative to end reliance on fossil fuels, Letters, 28 January). Many scientists have tried and failed to reproduce Martin Fleischmann and Stanley Pons’s initial report of cold fusion. After years of intense scrutiny, the mainstream scientific community overwhelmingly concluded by the early 1990s that cold fusion was not a credible idea supported by experimental evidence – a conclusion that stands after three decades of research.

The authors of the letter to the Guardian suggest that cold fusion research is now being suppressed from publication. In reality, credible, rigorous studies continue to be published in reputable journals (such as a 2019 study in Nature), but none of them has successfully observed cold fusion. The letter claims that companies have “been able to make these reactions work quite reliably”, but do not provide any evidence to support this.

The climate crisis requires immediate action, but those actions must be based on rigorous, reproducible science. It would be wonderful to live in a universe where cold fusion was a reality, but we cannot wave a magic wand and change the laws of nature.
Dr Philip Thomas
Postdoctoral research fellow, Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Exeter

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.

share Share facebook pinterest whatsapp x print

Similar Content

Top Tech Conferences & Events to Add to Your Calendar in 2025
Top Tech Conferences & Events to Add to Your Calendar in 2025
A cooling tower seen next to a hydrogen production plant.
A new tax credit for hydrogen helps out nuclear energy
A fireplace shown on a television.
The secret history of fireplace television
Authorities identify suspected shooter in Wisconsin school shooting
Authorities identify suspected shooter in Wisconsin school shooting
Trump a raison: le Canada n’est pas un vrai pays
Trump a raison: le Canada n’est pas un vrai pays
Collectibles are taking over the toy box – but now the grown-ups are playing too
Collectibles are taking over the toy box – but now the grown-ups are playing too
From Chaos to Clarity: Breaking Down the News | © 2025 | Daily News